By now, the Paine family in America, the ones descended from Stephen and Ann Chickering Paine, is quite a large family indeed. In this post, we will follow Nathan, a great great grandson of Stephen and Ann. His parents are Stephen and Sarah Thornton Paine, and he was born in Glocester, Rhode Island. He didn't stay there, though. He married Lillis Winsor, the daughter of Joseph and Deborah Mathewson Winsor, about 1765, and it appears that all of their children were born in Glocester.
"All", in this case encompasses at least 11 children and perhaps as many as 17. Again, there are a lot of Paines born in the right time period and with "family" names that would support a possibility that they are part of Nathan and Lillis's family, but I'm lacking corroborating information for several, and in some cases, the information on line is clearly erroneous. I have possibly contributed to the incorrect information, as in my last blog post I attributed Artemesia to this family. I now believe she would have been a daughter in law, not a daughter, as there is an Artemesia Payne buried with son Nathan Payne in Albion, Orleans County, New York. And incidentally, any reference you find to Nathaniel Payne is likely not this man, nor any of his immediate family.
So, with trepidation, I'll list his family as best I can, hoping as always for additions and corrections to this post.
The first child may have been Zattu/Zather/Zatto, born in 1767. (The name, it turns out, is Biblical. Zattu returned from Babylon to Jerusalem with Zerubabbel, in Old Testament times.) His wife is Abigail Eddy, the daughter of Jesse and Lydia Brown Eddy. Since we have both Brown and Eddy lines in our tree, I'm guessing that we are somehow related to these two people also, but they are not entered on my software. Their children are Eddy Brown, Winsor, Mary, Phebe, Arnold, Laura, Mathewson, and Peter. Zattu had gone to New York with most of the rest of his siblings, but apparently died in Rhode Island in either 1840 or 1847. I notice that none of the children were given his name!
The next child born seems to be Nathan, about 1769. He was married to someone named Artemisia, but apparently not until 1809. He is also said to have married Mary Carpenter, but I believe that marriage may apply to a different Nathan, later in the 19th century. His children are said to be Potter, Eli, Joseph, Daniel, Rebecca, Augustus, Sarah, and possibly Nathan and Lydia, but I've not found good records for this. Nathan died in Barre, Orleans County, New York in 1853.
Deborah is their first daughter, born in 1772. She married Enos Eddy, the son of Enos and Sarah Brown Eddy. Their children are Chloe, Lydia, Enos, Deborah, Joseph, Nathan, Lillis, Sarah, George, John, and Almira. She died in 1849 in Byron, Genessee County, New York.
Olive was born in 1774 and died in 1853 in Rome Center, Lenawee County, Michigan. She married Levi Hawley, the son of Stephen and Patience (maiden name not yet found) Hawley. (Please note that this name is also seen as Holley.) Their children are Henry, Eliza, William, Emeline, Levi, Betsey, Olive, Nelson, Thankful, and Nathan.
Stephen was born in 1776 and died in 1849 in Cattaragus County, New York. He married Sally/Sarah Angell, the daughter of Jesse and Amy Hammond Angell. Angell is another of our family names in Rhode Island, so there is a strong possibility that this Jesse is a distant relative, also. Their children are Harrison, Amy, Olive, Dorus (male, if you're wondering), Sally, Minerva, Maria, Marcy or Mercy, Stephen, and Mary Anne.
Samuel was born in 1778 and died in 1800, 1821. or 1868, either in New York or somewhere else. I am using the 1821 date in my notes because 1800 would be too young for him to have had as many children as he has, and 1868 would be a very long life. There is a Samuel Paine who died in 1868 in Yates, Orleans County, New York, but I am not yet convinced that it was this Samuel Paine. He married Lillis Cole, the daughter of Sisson and Elizabeth Hunter Cole. Their children are Winsor, Caroline, Samuel, Amos, Cynthia, Lizzie, Lyman, Lillis, Charlotte, Damon, and Jackson-unless, of course, some of these names belong to the son Samuel. Based on birth dates, either could be correct. More research is called for!
I actually have two candidates for daughters born in 1780, with no mention that there were twins born to this couple. I am fairly confident that Thankful is their daughter, born in 1780 and died in 1864 in Seneca, Ontario County, New York. She married Daniel Colwell, the son of Daniel and Mercy Hopkins Colwell, and then married Nathan Whitney, the son of Jonathan and Esther Parkhurst Whitney. Her children were all with Daniel Colwell. They are David, John, Daniel, Elvira, Minerva, Angelina, Nathan, Christopher, Oliver, and William.
The other possibility is Lydia, and there is very little reliable information about her. She is reported to have died in 1811 in Seneca, Ontario County, New York, and is buried in the Whitney Cemetery (see above). She died "in her 38th year" which would likely mean her birth year is 1774 or possibly 1775. She had a daughter, Relief, and another infant who is buried with her. Her husband is Joseph Gibbs but he is still a mystery.
Asa was born in 1782 and died in 1868 in (possibly Barre), Orleans County, New York. He married Amy Angell, who was also a daughter of Jesse and Amy Hammond Angell (see above; siblings married siblings). Their children are Valorus, Cordelia, Sophronia, Veeder, Asa, James, Christopher, Amy and possibly Maria and Sarah. Amy died in 1845, and he then married married Jane Rosabella, maiden name unknown, and they had three children, Rosabella, Elva, and Ellen. He may have also married Mrs. Zilpha Burch, after Jane's death in 1849.
Sally, possibly Sarah, was born in 1784 and died in 1822, possibly in Orleans County, New York. (She is not the Sallie Paine who died in Vermont in 1868.) She married William Parker, the son of Cornelius and Sarah (maiden name not yet found) Parker. Their children are Lydia, Savilla, Lovina, Daniel, Isaac, Adeline, William, and Olive.
Christopher was born in 1787 and died in 1855 at Albion, Orleans County, New York. He married Laura Paine, the daughter of Zattu and Abigail Eddy Paine. Laura was a niece to Christopher, which seems unusual but perhaps there is something here that I am not understanding. Their children are Martin, Oville, Celinda, Albert, Christopher, William, and John.
I have names for three more potential children of Nathan and Lillis, but very little is to be found about them and so I will mention them only briefly, as possibilities. There may have been a son John, born in 1767 and died in 1821. He may have married Hannah. Joseph was born about 1774 and died in 1862 in Ontario, New York. Finally, Israel was born about 1784 and died in 1813. He may have married Lovica. That is all that I have about those three men, and I am not at all sure that they belong in this family.
As we have seen, there are a lot of Paines in Rhode Island and New York, especially, and it is hard to differentiate between one Stephen and another, one John and another, one Nathan and another. I have three genealogy wishes for this family. First, I'd like to know for sure whether the three "possibles" actually belong to this couple. And of course I'd like to have the information I'm missing as to dates and places. The last question I have is "Why?" Why did Nathan and his family move from Glocester, Rhode Island to New York. Generally there is a push-pull when a family pulls up stakes and moves on. What pushed them from Rhode Island? And what pulled them to New York, which is not the safest of places until after the War of 1812?
This is the last of the posts on the Paine families who are our ancestors, as we "daughtered out" with Deborah who married Enos Eddy. It's been both fun and frustrating, and I'd sure love to learn more about all of them.