The still not found family of Jacob Geiger 1748-1791

Oh my goodness!  This is a difficult family to write about, because everyone has a different opinion on this and everyone seems to have one document that points in their own opinion.  But we know we need to have at least two, and optimally many more, documents to allow us to form a belief based on facts.  That is mostly lacking at this point with this family.  

Jacob Geiger was born in 1748 in New Hanover, Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, the son of Valentine and Sarah (maiden name not known, she was the widow of someone named Vetato or another spelling) Geiger.  He died February 24, 1791 in what is now Berkeley County, West Virginia.  He married Elizabeth Shutz or Schultz, the daughter of Daniel and Catherine Walter Schultz in 1776 in Frederick County, Maryland, so he was already on the move.  Two short months after the marriage, the first of their children was born.

Anthony Geiger was born in 1776 in Frederick County, Maryland and died in 1836 in or near Churubusco, Whitley County, Indiana.  He also was not a "stay in one place" kind of person.  He married Mary Kirk, daughter of Joseph and Sarah (maiden name not known) in 1797 in Berkeley County, West Virginia.  Their children are Joseph, Sarah, Elizabeth, John, Jacob, Ann, Margaret, Mary Ann, Anthony, Thomas, and Daniel.  I will follow this family in my next blog post.  

After that family, the story gets pretty murky.  Jacob was born in 1778 and reportedly (I have found no records) died in 1821 in Preble County, Ohio.  He may or may not have married an Elizabeth Houdyshell, and he may or may not have married an Anna Katharina Auwaeter. Those names are on Ancestry trees, with no supporting documents.  I am not locating a Jacob Geiger in the 1820 census in Ohio, so the mystery is deep.  There are several Jacob Geigers in Pennsylvania but I can't say that any of them appear to fit directly into this family.

There is even less information regarding the rest of their children, but I will list them here for whatever it's worth.  Catherine was born in 1780, Johannes or possibly John in 1781, Elizabeth in 1785, Anne in 1786, and Daniel in 1787.  I have hints of possible first names for some of the spouses, but I am not going to share them here as they all appear questionable to me.  

Update: A strong possibility for Anne Geiger's (1786) spouse would be Henry Nisley or Neisley, the son of Abraham and Elizabeth Spitler Nisley.  They lived in Fairfield County, Ohio, and may have had the following children-Catherine, Elizabeth, Detwiler, and George Washington.  There may be others, and of course I'm lacking in the documents that would give me some degree of confidence.  

Clearly, this is one of the least researched families I've written about.  Perhaps other family researchers are as confused and unconvinced as I am.  I would be especially interested in learning about Jacob and any military service he might have been connected with.  Lord Dunmore's War, the Revolutionary War, ongoing strife with the native tribes that continued after "peace"?  Perhaps it was all of the above, but I just don't know.  Regardless, we know he lived in interesting times, in a dangerous place.  He's one family ancestor I would really like to talk to!